Eqogo Logo

Cheddar

43 Products

Each time you see a score on Eqogo, remember that it is relative to its product category. What does this mean?

Select 2 to 5 items to compare in detail.
99
in Cheddar Cheese

Rogue Creamery CaCow Belle Spiced Cheddar Rogue Creamery

Scored Product Attributes

99
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Recycled Secondary Packaging

Gluten Free

Recyclable Secondary Packaging

Organic Milk

Organic Cocoa

Antibiotic Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

This CERT recognizes businesses that meet high standards of social and environmental performance, accountability and transparency as certified by B Lab.

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet organic standards set by Oregon Tilth, focusing on practices like soil health, biodiversity and the prohibition of synthetic chemicals.

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet USDA organic standards, ensuring they are produced without synthetic chemicals and with practices promoting soil health, biodiversity and water conservation.

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

This brand uses renewable energy sources such as solar, wind, or hydro power to run its operations.
65
in Cheddar Cheese

Trader Joe’s Sliced New Zealand Organic Cheddar

The lush, green pastures of New Zealand's organic dairy farms provide the jumping off point for our Sliced New Zealand Organic Cheddar. The milk used to produce this distinctive cheese comes from cows raised on family owned dairies and treated to a diet of the abundant organic clover and grasses that blanket the pastures of New Zealand's dairy lands. Moderate temperatures (60-75ºF), flowing mountain streams, and abundant rainfall mean that there is ample pasture for grazing year round. Because of their diet, the cows produce incredibly rich and flavorful milk, and that milk, in turn, produces incredibly rich and flavorful cheese. Trader Joe's Sliced New Zealand Organic Cheddar is aged for three to six months, enough time to allow its flavorful, fresh and creamy profile to fully emerge. It's excellent on burgers, as a quick snack, and of course, on sandwiches, cold or hot - try it on a grilled cheese with arugula and fig butter!

Scored Product Attributes

65
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Artificial Color Free

Artificial Flavor Free

MSG free

Organic Milk

Artificial Preservative Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet organic standards set by Oregon Tilth, focusing on practices like soil health, biodiversity and the prohibition of synthetic chemicals.

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet USDA organic standards, ensuring they are produced without synthetic chemicals and with practices promoting soil health, biodiversity and water conservation.
Warranty: Money Back Guarantee

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Social criteria factor Social

Company participates in community outreach or activism programs.

This brand supports Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, promoting a diverse and inclusive workplace and community.
icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

Company that is taking steps to eliminate all plastics in their production and packaging.
55
in Cheddar Cheese

Organic Valley Thick Cut Shredded Sharp Cheddar, 6 oz | Buy Organic Valley Near You

A buttery, tangy cheese with just the right amount of crumble, our Sharp Cheddar is aged to bring out its natural bite. Whether you're sprinkling this vegetarian-friendly cheese on eggs, melting it in casseroles, or just enjoying it on its own, we think you'll be able to taste the extra goodness that comes from using organic milk.

Scored Product Attributes

55
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Pesticide Free

Organic Milk

Antibiotic Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet organic standards set by Oregon Tilth, focusing on practices like soil health, biodiversity and the prohibition of synthetic chemicals.

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet USDA organic standards, ensuring they are produced without synthetic chemicals and with practices promoting soil health, biodiversity and water conservation.

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

This brand uses renewable energy sources such as solar, wind, or hydro power to run its operations.

This brand is LEED certified, demonstrating its commitment to sustainable building practices and energy efficiency.
55
in Cheddar Cheese

Organic Valley Grassmilk Raw Cheddar, 8 oz | Buy Organic Valley Near You

Beginning with unpasteurized milk from grassfed cows, our Grassmilk Raw Cheddar is aged a minimum of 60 days to develop its flavors. This vegetarian-friendly cheese is usually white, but its color can change with the seasons, as cows graze on a variety of plants throughout the year.

Scored Product Attributes

55
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Pesticide Free

Organic Milk

Antibiotic Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet organic standards set by Oregon Tilth, focusing on practices like soil health, biodiversity and the prohibition of synthetic chemicals.

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet USDA organic standards, ensuring they are produced without synthetic chemicals and with practices promoting soil health, biodiversity and water conservation.

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

This brand uses renewable energy sources such as solar, wind, or hydro power to run its operations.

This brand is LEED certified, demonstrating its commitment to sustainable building practices and energy efficiency.
40
in Cheddar Cheese

Sierra Nevada Cheese Company Organic Raw Milk Cheddar - sierranevadacheese

Our raw cheeses showcase the complex array of flavor resulting from naturally-occurring healthy micro-organisms present in our fresh milk sourced from our own Organic Grass-Fed Farms.

Scored Product Attributes

40
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Organic Milk

rBST Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet USDA organic standards, ensuring they are produced without synthetic chemicals and with practices promoting soil health, biodiversity and water conservation.

This CERT verifies that food products and production processes comply with kosher dietary laws as certified by the Orthodox Rabbinical Council (ORC).
40
in Cheddar Cheese

Sierra Nevada Cheese Company Organic Raw Milk Smoked Cheddar - sierranevadacheese

Our raw cheeses showcase the complex array of flavor resulting from naturally-occurring healthy micro-organisms present in our fresh milk sourced from our own Organic Grass-Fed Farms.

Scored Product Attributes

40
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Organic Milk

rBST Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet USDA organic standards, ensuring they are produced without synthetic chemicals and with practices promoting soil health, biodiversity and water conservation.

This CERT verifies that food products and production processes comply with kosher dietary laws as certified by the Orthodox Rabbinical Council (ORC).
31
in Cheddar Cheese

Wegmans Wegmans

Scored Product Attributes

31
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

Organic Milk

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

This CERT verifies that agricultural products meet USDA organic standards, ensuring they are produced without synthetic chemicals and with practices promoting soil health, biodiversity and water conservation.

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Social criteria factor Social

This brand supports Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, promoting a diverse and inclusive workplace and community.
icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

Company that is taking steps to eliminate all plastics in their production and packaging.
17
in Cheddar Cheese

The Cheese Guy Medium Yellow Cheddar

This mild yellow kosher cheddar cheese has a firm body and a smooth, creamy flavor and consistency.

Scored Product Attributes

17
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

Antibiotic Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

This CERT verifies that food products and production processes comply with kosher dietary laws as certified by the Orthodox Union (OU), ensuring they meet strict Jewish dietary standards.
17
in Cheddar Cheese

The Cheese Guy CY Raw Milk Vermont Artisanal Medium Cheddar

An aged kosher medium cheddar cheese with notes of honey, lush butter and fruit tones.

Scored Product Attributes

17
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

Antibiotic Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

This CERT verifies that food products and production processes comply with kosher dietary laws as certified by the Orthodox Union (OU), ensuring they meet strict Jewish dietary standards.
8
in Cheddar Cheese

Trader Joe’s Cheddar Cheese with Caramelized Onions

While in England visiting a farm, famous for their flavored cheese artistry, we were introduced to this Cheddar Cheese with Caramelized Onions. It’s crafted for us on an established estate, idyllically situated between the rolling Dorset Downs and the Jurassic Coast—an international world heritage site, lush with pastures. With more than 40 years of traditional cheese making experience, a famed farm on this estate transforms rich, creamy milk from local grazing herds (within a 30 mile radius) into beautiful, full-bodied farmhouse Cheddar. Inspired by a classically British ploughman’s lunch pairing (cheese & chutney), these blending artists mix caramelized onion marmalade into the Cheddar, giving it a balanced sweet-savory bite and pleasing onion aroma. It’s firm, creamy and adorned throughout with bits of onion. It’s memorable! Trader Joe’s Cheddar Cheese with Caramelized Onions is excellent served simply—cut and accompanied by crackers or small slices of rustic bread. It also melts exceptionally well, which makes it a fun topping for burgers, grilled cheeses or pizzas. We also enjoy the sweetness it brings to cream sauces.

Scored Product Attributes

8
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Artificial Color Free

Artificial Flavor Free

MSG free

Artificial Preservative Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: Money Back Guarantee

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Social criteria factor Social

Company participates in community outreach or activism programs.

This brand supports Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, promoting a diverse and inclusive workplace and community.
icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

Company that is taking steps to eliminate all plastics in their production and packaging.
8
in Cheddar Cheese

Trader Joe’s New Zealand Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Amidst the pastoral splendor and rolling, verdant hills of the New Zealand countryside, you’ll find countless dairy farms covering the land. On these farms, grass-fed cows produce remarkably rich, deliciously creamy milk. On one such farm in particular, the master cheesemakers use this milk to craft a soft, easy-eating Cheddar, then age it for six to twelve months to give it a nice sharp note and full-flavored profile. And after all that, they ship it off to us, where it becomes Trader Joe’s New Zealand Grass Fed Sharp Cheddar.

Scored Product Attributes

8
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Artificial Color Free

Artificial Flavor Free

MSG free

Artificial Preservative Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: Money Back Guarantee

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Social criteria factor Social

Company participates in community outreach or activism programs.

This brand supports Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, promoting a diverse and inclusive workplace and community.
icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

Company that is taking steps to eliminate all plastics in their production and packaging.
8
in Cheddar Cheese

Trader Joe’s Cheddar Cheese with Scotch Bonnet Chili Peppers

Famed for their importance in Caribbean cuisine, and named for their physical resemblance to a woolen tam o’ shanter cap, Scotch bonnet chilis have a delicate sweetness to them and a remarkable level of heat – a few orders of magnitude hotter than jalapeños, for reference. And as the makers of Trader Joe’s Cheddar with Scotch Bonnet Chilis and Red Peppers have found, these qualities make them a natural companion to the inherent nuttiness and crumbly texture of a classic English Cheddar. Using a mix of time-tested cheesemaking techniques and state of the art equipment, they flavor this savory Cheddar with sweet and fiery Scotch bonnet chili relish to great acclaim in supermarkets across the U.K. – and we’re proud to say that we’re the first to carry it across the pond. A delight for heat-seekers and fromage fans of all stripes, this Cheddar balances its blend of sweet, spicy, and creamy with remarkable grace. It makes a great addition to grilled cheese sandwiches, mac & cheese casseroles, or even a sweet and hot potatoes au gratin. Looking to turn up the heat at your next get-together? Pair this Cheddar up with spicy cold cuts like pepperoni and capicola for a scorching charcuterie plate – just make sure to take the cheese out of the fridge at least 30 minutes before serving for maximum flavor.

Scored Product Attributes

8
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Artificial Color Free

Artificial Flavor Free

MSG free

Artificial Preservative Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: Money Back Guarantee

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Social criteria factor Social

Company participates in community outreach or activism programs.

This brand supports Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, promoting a diverse and inclusive workplace and community.
icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

Company that is taking steps to eliminate all plastics in their production and packaging.
8
in Cheddar Cheese

Trader Joe’s Sliced Sharp Cheddar Cheese

Trader Joe’s Sliced Sharp Cheddar is made under the supervision of Wisconsin Master Cheesemakers, using milk from local family farms. It’s a traditional Cheddar, made using the time-honored cheddaring process. Aged four to six months, it develops a rich, creamy, nutty flavor and almost-but-not-quite-ready-to-crumble texture. Ideal for burgers, sandwiches, panini, tuna melts, and omelets.

Scored Product Attributes

8
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Artificial Color Free

Artificial Flavor Free

MSG free

Artificial Preservative Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: Money Back Guarantee

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Social criteria factor Social

Company participates in community outreach or activism programs.

This brand supports Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, promoting a diverse and inclusive workplace and community.
icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

Company that is taking steps to eliminate all plastics in their production and packaging.
8
in Cheddar Cheese

Trader Joe’s Unexpected Cheddar Cheese

Trader Joe’s Unexpected Cheddar looks like an aged Cheddar. At first bite, it tastes like an aged Cheddar. And then something entirely unexpected happens. The smooth creaminess of the Cheddar gives way to a tangy flavor and slightly crumbly texture, a subtle hint of salt crystallization is discovered, and it begins to taste like an aged Parmesan. Unexpected indeed! Our cheese makers, based in Wisconsin, have origins in Valdastico, in Italy’s mountainous, Northeastern Veneto region. In this cheese, they’ve combined the best qualities of hard Italian cheeses like Parmesan with the best qualities of finely crafted American Cheddar and created a semi-hard cheese that pairs well with lighter-bodied red wines (think Pinot Noir) or pale ales. Joined by crusty bread, a slice of your favorite salami, and Fig & Olive Crisps, this cheese is unexpectedly perfect. As with most cheeses, we suggest letting Unexpected Cheddar breathe at room temperature for about 30 minutes prior to serving. If you’re prepping a platter, unwrap the cheese and resist the temptation to cut right in. Your patience will be rewarded with cheese that really lives up to its flavor potential. It really is worth the wait.

Scored Product Attributes

8
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Artificial Color Free

Artificial Flavor Free

MSG free

Artificial Preservative Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: Money Back Guarantee

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Social criteria factor Social

Company participates in community outreach or activism programs.

This brand supports Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, promoting a diverse and inclusive workplace and community.
icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

Company that is taking steps to eliminate all plastics in their production and packaging.
8
in Cheddar Cheese

Trader Joe’s Everything but the Bagel Cheddar Cheese

Every now and then, we introduce a product that attains a kind of instantaneous iconic status. Our Everything But the Bagel Sesame Seasoning Blend definitely falls into that category. Since its debut back in 2017, it has remained perennially popular, and it’s easy to see why: it turns out that garlic, onion, poppy, sesame, and sea salt synergize with a whole lot more than just bagels. Take, for instance, this new addition to our cheese section, Trader Joe’s Everything But the Bagel Cheddar Cheese. It’s crafted just for us by an expert cheesemaker, who infuses each wheel with the very same seasoning we sell on our shelves, so that each bite is rich with the maximalist mix of aromatic alliums, crunchy seeds, and savory spice you know and love. In addition to making an excellent cheese to simply snack upon, we find that these pops of flavor and texture also make this bold and tangy Cheddar a great choice for a grilled cheese or macaroni bake, or slicing and serving atop a nice burger on a Brioche Bun. Try it on your next cheese board or charcuterie spread the next time you have company over. And if you feel like bringing everything full circle, try melting a slice over a toasted bagel with a fried egg and bacon for an unbeatable breakfast sandwich.

Scored Product Attributes

8
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Artificial Color Free

Artificial Flavor Free

MSG free

Artificial Preservative Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: Money Back Guarantee

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Social criteria factor Social

Company participates in community outreach or activism programs.

This brand supports Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, promoting a diverse and inclusive workplace and community.
icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

Company that is taking steps to eliminate all plastics in their production and packaging.
8
in Cheddar Cheese

Trader Joe’s Shredded Unexpected Cheddar Cheese

Shredded Unexpected Cheddar Cheese is a finely crafted American Cheddar fused with the tangy, crumbly texture of a hard, aged Italian cheese. It is smooth, creamy, and surprisingly satisfying for cheese lovers. This eight-ounce package contains large shreds, ready for topping salads, soups, and open-faced sandwiches. It also works well in quesadillas, chili, sauces, and macaroni & cheese.

Scored Product Attributes

8
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Artificial Color Free

Artificial Flavor Free

MSG free

Artificial Preservative Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: Money Back Guarantee

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Social criteria factor Social

Company participates in community outreach or activism programs.

This brand supports Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (DEI) initiatives, promoting a diverse and inclusive workplace and community.
icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

Company that is taking steps to eliminate all plastics in their production and packaging.
3
in Cheddar Cheese

Carr Valley Cheese 1 Year Cheddar Cheese | Carr Valley Cheese

Carr Valley 1 Year Cheddar Cheese

Scored Product Attributes

3
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Recycled Secondary Packaging

CFC Free

Biodegradable Packaging

rBST Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: 45 - 90 Day

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing item origin Origins
Made in Wisconsin, United States of America
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Amos Miller Organic Farm Raw Sheep Cheddar Cheese per lb Amos Miller Organic Farm

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Soy Free

Organic Milk

Hormone Free

Antibiotic Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Amos Miller Organic Farm Hard Goat Cheddar Salted per lb Amos Miller Organic Farm

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Soy Free

Organic Milk

Hormone Free

Antibiotic Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Henning’s Cheese Henning's Medium Cheddar Cheese

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

Antibiotic Free

rBST Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: 20 - 34 Day

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

- Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
icon representing item origin Origins
Made in Wisconsin, United States of America
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Henning’s Cheese Henning's Aged Cheddar Cheese

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

Antibiotic Free

rBST Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: 20 - 34 Day

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

- Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
icon representing item origin Origins
Made in Wisconsin, United States of America
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Eichtens Cheeses, Gifts & Foods Cheddar Cheese, White Aged 1 Year

Buy a block of aged white cheddar aged over 1 year from Eichtens Cheese. Various ages are available. Mild to Aged all-natural white hard/semi-hard Cheddar.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

GMO Free

Artificial Color Free

Preservative Free

Artificial Flavor Free

Antibiotic Free

rBST Free

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

- Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
icon representing item origin Origins
Made in Center City, Minnesota, United States of America
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Sartori Old World Cheddar

Sweet and savory with a buttery finish. Sharp notes highlight the robust flavor of this white cheddar. Taste Notes: Want sharp flavor? You got it. Savory meets buttery with notes of fruit. Theres nothing quite like it. Our Italian cheddars bring a unique taste profile and excitement to every occasion.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

rBST Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: 1 - 19 Day
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Sartori MontAmor Cheddar

Smooth white cheddar with a hint of Parmesan a Sartori original that's indescribably delicious. Taste Notes: Sweet and savory meets a familiar parmesan note that will keep you coming back for more. Our Italian cheddars bring a unique taste profile and excitement to every occasion.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

rBST Free

icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
Warranty: 1 - 19 Day
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Williams Cheese Company Sharp Cheddar Stick 8 oz.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

BPA Free

Gluten Free

Artificial Flavor Free

Artificial Preservative Free

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

- Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Williams Cheese Company Smoked Cheddar 8 oz.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

BPA Free

Gluten Free

Artificial Flavor Free

Artificial Preservative Free

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

- Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Williams Cheese Company Sharp Cheddar 16 oz.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

BPA Free

Gluten Free

Artificial Flavor Free

Artificial Preservative Free

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

- Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Kerrygold Aged Cheddar Cheese | Kerrygold USA

Kerrygold's Aged Cheddar Cheese goes through a careful grading process as it matures in order to guarantee only the very best rich and full-bodied cheddar. Read More.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

Nut Free

rBST Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Kerrygold Reserve Cheddar Cheese | Kerrygold USA

Kerrygold's Reserve Cheddar Cheese is made with the milk of Irish grass-fed cows and is aged for an additional year which results in an intense flavor which is still rich and smooth. Read More.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

Nut Free

rBST Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Kerrygold Skellig Cheese | Kerrygold USA

Kerrygold's Skellig Cheese is made from the milk of Irish grass-fed cows. Offering an array of flavors that make it perfect for cooking or on a cheeseboard.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

Nut Free

rBST Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Beecher's Handmade Cheese Flagship Cheese

The first wheel of Flagship, Beechers signature cheese, was handcrafted just as Beechers Handmade Cheese opened its doors in Seattles historic Pike Place Market in November of 2003.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Preservative Free

Artificial Flavor Free

rBST Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Beecher's Handmade Cheese Flagship Reserve Cheese

Flagship Reserve is a special version of our signature Flagship cheese. It is made only on days when the milk composition is just right. The last curds on the table from these makes are used to produce Flagship Reserve truckles as it allows for slightly lower moisture, higher salt content and thus a richer taste and te

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Preservative Free

Artificial Flavor Free

rBST Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Beecher's Handmade Cheese Beecher's Flagship Extra-Aged Cheese

Looking for Beecher's Flagship Extra-Aged Cheese? Find the 4-Year Aged Flagship that Ships in Just 2 Days. Buy Authentic and Original Food Now!

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Preservative Free

Artificial Flavor Free

rBST Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Plymouth Cheese Original Plymouth

This original Coolidge family formula was discovered by Jesse Werner on a frayed scrap of paper, taped to the walls of the old Plymouth factory.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

rBST Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Plymouth Cheese Black Truffle

Black Truffle is the delicate mingling of the Original Plymouth recipe sailed metaphorically to the shores of Tuscany.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

rBST Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Plymouth Cheese Sage & Herbs

Our Sage & Herbs cheddar is a lover, not a fighter.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

rBST Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Bunker Hill Cheese Mild Cheddar (Smoked) - Bunker Hill Cheese

Smoked with hickory wood chips. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Microbial Coagulant, Cheese Cultures, Annatto.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

rBST Free

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

- Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume

This brand is owned and operated by women.
icon representing item origin Origins
Made in Berlin, Ohio, United States of America
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Bunker Hill Cheese Mild Cheddar Cheese - Bunker Hill Cheese

Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Microbial Coagulant, Cheese Cultures, Annatto.

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

rBST Free

Good To Know - Brand Attributes

icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

- Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume

This brand is owned and operated by women.
icon representing item origin Origins
Made in Berlin, Ohio, United States of America
1
in Cheddar Cheese

Gossner Foods Mild Cheddar Slice

From humble beginnings in the village of Cheddar, England to the grand Poobah of go-to cheese for any occasion, Cheddar has been centuries in the making. And we've refined and perfected the craft of making the world's best here at Gossner's. Aged a minimum of 60 days, our mild, medium and sharp cheddar has an unparalle

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

rBST Free

1
in Cheddar Cheese

Hoosier Hill Farm White Cheddar Cheese Powder - Hoosier Hill Farm

Hoosier Hill Farms White Cheddar Cheese Powder is made with microbial rennet rather than rennet made from animal sources. Shop our online store today!

Scored Product Attributes

1
icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

Gluten Free

Your Selections

Select 2 to 5 items to compare