Eqogo Logo
category Start typing to see results

    Cheddar

    74 Products

    Each time you see a score on Eqogo, remember that it is relative to its product category. What does this mean?

    Select 2 to 5 items to compare in detail.
    16
    in Cheddar Cheese

    The Cheese Guy CY Raw Milk Vermont Artisanal Medium Cheddar

    $12.00 Shop now launch
    View description
    An aged kosher medium cheddar cheese with notes of honey, lush butter and fruit tones.

    Scored Product Attributes

    16
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    Antibiotic Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

    This CERT verifies that food products and production processes comply with kosher dietary laws as certified by the Orthodox Union (OU), ensuring they meet strict Jewish dietary standards.
    14
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Green Valley Creamery Green Valley Creamery Lactose Free

    $7.49 Shop now launch
    View description
    A smooth and creamy, delicately ripened mild cheddar perfect for all recipes calling for cheese. Made with simple ingredients, this real dairy cheese is a good source of protein and calcium. It's delicious shredded, sliced, melted, you name it.

    Scored Product Attributes

    14
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Lactose Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

    This CERT verifies that food products are low in FODMAPs, making them suitable for individuals with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) and other digestive disorders.

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

    This brand uses renewable energy sources such as solar, wind, or hydro power to run its operations.
    14
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Green Valley Creamery Green Valley Creamery Lactose Free

    $7.29 Shop now launch
    View description
    Perfectly buttery and balanced with a smooth finish, our lactose-free mild cheddar means happy guts and bright smiles accompany every cheesy meal. Scramble it into your eggs, top your chili, smother your nachos, or pair it with potatoes. Tastes and melts like real dairy cheese, because it is!

    Scored Product Attributes

    14
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Lactose Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

    This CERT verifies that food products are low in FODMAPs, making them suitable for individuals with irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) and other digestive disorders.

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

    This brand uses renewable energy sources such as solar, wind, or hydro power to run its operations.
    9
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Sierra Nevada Cheese Company Graziers Raw Milk Cheese Medium Cheddar - sierranevadacheese

    $7.49 Shop now launch
    View description
    Graziers Cheese is naturally higher in omega 3s and CLAs and made only with milk from Certified Graziers Cows on pasture for more than 300 days per year.

    Scored Product Attributes

    9
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    GMO Free

    rBST Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications

    This CERT verifies that food products and production processes comply with kosher dietary laws as certified by the Orthodox Rabbinical Council (ORC).
    3
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Carr Valley Cheese Baby Cheddar Cheese | Carr Valley Cheese

    $4.99 Shop now launch
    View description
    Carr Valley Baby Cheddar Cheese is very young, 30 to 60 days old

    Scored Product Attributes

    3
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Biodegradable Packaging

    rBST Free

    Recycled Secondary Packaging

    CFC Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
    Warranty: 45 - 90 Day

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing item origin Origins
    Made in Wisconsin, United States of America
    3
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Carr Valley Cheese 10 Year Cheddar Cheese | Carr Valley Cheese

    $15.49 Shop now launch
    View description
    Carr Valley 10 Year Cheddar Cheese

    Scored Product Attributes

    3
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Biodegradable Packaging

    rBST Free

    Recycled Secondary Packaging

    CFC Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
    Warranty: 45 - 90 Day

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing item origin Origins
    Made in Wisconsin, United States of America
    3
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Carr Valley Cheese Cave Aged Cheddar Cheese | Carr Valley Cheese

    $8.49 Shop now launch
    View description
    Carr Valley Cave Aged Cheddar Cheese

    Scored Product Attributes

    3
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Recycled Secondary Packaging

    CFC Free

    Biodegradable Packaging

    rBST Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
    Warranty: 45 - 90 Day

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing item origin Origins
    Made in Wisconsin, United States of America
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Amos Miller Organic Farm Hard Goat Cheddar Salted per lb Amos Miller Organic Farm

    $17.00 Shop now launch
    View description

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Organic Milk

    Hormone Free

    Antibiotic Free

    GMO Free

    Soy Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Amos Miller Organic Farm Raw Sheep Cheddar Cheese per lb Amos Miller Organic Farm

    $23.00 Shop now launch
    View description

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    GMO Free

    Soy Free

    Organic Milk

    Hormone Free

    Antibiotic Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Henning’s Cheese Henning's Medium Cheddar Cheese

    $6.69 Shop now launch
    View description

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    Antibiotic Free

    rBST Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
    Warranty: 20 - 34 Day

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

    - Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
    icon representing item origin Origins
    Made in Wisconsin, United States of America
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Henning’s Cheese Henning's Aged Cheddar Cheese

    $7.29 Shop now launch
    View description

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    Antibiotic Free

    rBST Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
    Warranty: 20 - 34 Day

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

    - Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
    icon representing item origin Origins
    Made in Wisconsin, United States of America
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Eichtens Cheeses, Gifts & Foods Cheddar Cheese, White Aged 1 Year

    $5.50 Shop now launch
    View description
    Buy a block of aged white cheddar aged over 1 year from Eichtens Cheese. Various ages are available. Mild to Aged all-natural white hard/semi-hard Cheddar.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Artificial Color Free

    Preservative Free

    Artificial Flavor Free

    Antibiotic Free

    rBST Free

    GMO Free

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

    - Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
    icon representing item origin Origins
    Made in Center City, Minnesota, United States of America
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Sartori Old World Cheddar

    $6.99 Shop now launch
    View description
    Sweet and savory with a buttery finish. Sharp notes highlight the robust flavor of this white cheddar. Taste Notes: Want sharp flavor? You got it. Savory meets buttery with notes of fruit. Theres nothing quite like it. Our Italian cheddars bring a unique taste profile and excitement to every occasion.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    rBST Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
    Warranty: 1 - 19 Day
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Sartori MontAmor Cheddar

    $6.99 Shop now launch
    View description
    Smooth white cheddar with a hint of Parmesan a Sartori original that's indescribably delicious. Taste Notes: Sweet and savory meets a familiar parmesan note that will keep you coming back for more. Our Italian cheddars bring a unique taste profile and excitement to every occasion.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    rBST Free

    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Certifications
    Warranty: 1 - 19 Day
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Williams Cheese Company Sharp Cheddar Stick 8 oz.

    $3.89 Shop now launch
    View description

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    BPA Free

    Gluten Free

    Artificial Flavor Free

    Artificial Preservative Free

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

    - Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Williams Cheese Company Sharp Cheddar 16 oz.

    $3.29 Shop now launch
    View description

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    BPA Free

    Gluten Free

    Artificial Flavor Free

    Artificial Preservative Free

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

    - Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Williams Cheese Company Smoked Cheddar 8 oz.

    $3.89 Shop now launch
    View description

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    BPA Free

    Gluten Free

    Artificial Flavor Free

    Artificial Preservative Free

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

    - Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Kerrygold Aged Cheddar Cheese | Kerrygold USA

    $7.99 Shop now launch
    View description
    Kerrygold's Aged Cheddar Cheese goes through a careful grading process as it matures in order to guarantee only the very best rich and full-bodied cheddar. Read More.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    rBST Free

    Gluten Free

    Nut Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Beecher's Handmade Cheese Flagship Cheese

    $15.00 Shop now launch
    View description
    The first wheel of Flagship, Beechers signature cheese, was handcrafted just as Beechers Handmade Cheese opened its doors in Seattles historic Pike Place Market in November of 2003.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Preservative Free

    Artificial Flavor Free

    rBST Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Beecher's Handmade Cheese Beecher's Flagship Extra-Aged Cheese

    $17.00 Shop now launch
    View description
    Looking for Beecher's Flagship Extra-Aged Cheese? Find the 4-Year Aged Flagship that Ships in Just 2 Days. Buy Authentic and Original Food Now!

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    rBST Free

    Preservative Free

    Artificial Flavor Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Kerrygold Reserve Cheddar Cheese | Kerrygold USA

    $7.99 Shop now launch
    View description
    Kerrygold's Reserve Cheddar Cheese is made with the milk of Irish grass-fed cows and is aged for an additional year which results in an intense flavor which is still rich and smooth. Read More.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    Nut Free

    rBST Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Beecher's Handmade Cheese Flagship Reserve Cheese

    $17.00 Shop now launch
    View description
    Flagship Reserve is a special version of our signature Flagship cheese. It is made only on days when the milk composition is just right. The last curds on the table from these makes are used to produce Flagship Reserve truckles as it allows for slightly lower moisture, higher salt content and thus a richer taste and te

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Preservative Free

    Artificial Flavor Free

    rBST Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Kerrygold Skellig Cheese | Kerrygold USA

    $6.99 Shop now launch
    View description
    Kerrygold's Skellig Cheese is made from the milk of Irish grass-fed cows. Offering an array of flavors that make it perfect for cooking or on a cheeseboard.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    Nut Free

    rBST Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Finlandia Finlandia’s Cheddar-Gruyere

    $7.89 Shop now launch
    View description
    Finlandia’s Cheddar-Gruyere is a bold blend of tangy Cheddar and smooth Gruyere. It is remarkably rich and melts in your mouth with every bite. In the Nordic region, this great tasting Cheddar style cheese is a popular family snack known for its exceptional taste.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    GMO Free

    Lactose Free

    rBST Free

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Environmental criteria factor Enviro

    This brand actively engages in regenerative agriculture, directly implementing practices that enhance soil health and biodiversity.
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Plymouth Cheese Original Plymouth

    $13.00 Shop now launch
    View description
    This original Coolidge family formula was discovered by Jesse Werner on a frayed scrap of paper, taped to the walls of the old Plymouth factory.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    rBST Free

    Gluten Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Plymouth Cheese Black Truffle

    $14.00 Shop now launch
    View description
    Black Truffle is the delicate mingling of the Original Plymouth recipe sailed metaphorically to the shores of Tuscany.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    rBST Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Plymouth Cheese Sage & Herbs

    $13.00 Shop now launch
    View description
    Our Sage & Herbs cheddar is a lover, not a fighter.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    rBST Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Bunker Hill Cheese Mild Cheddar (Smoked) - Bunker Hill Cheese

    $4.99 Shop now launch
    View description
    Smoked with hickory wood chips. Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Microbial Coagulant, Cheese Cultures, Annatto.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    rBST Free

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

    - Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume

    This brand is owned and operated by women.
    icon representing item origin Origins
    Made in Berlin, Ohio, United States of America
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Bunker Hill Cheese Mild Cheddar Cheese - Bunker Hill Cheese

    $4.99 Shop now launch
    View description
    Ingredients: Pasteurized Milk, Salt, Microbial Coagulant, Cheese Cultures, Annatto.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    rBST Free

    Good To Know - Brand Attributes

    icon representing Governance criteria factor Governance

    - Brand must describe itself in some way or form as family owned. Do not assume

    This brand is owned and operated by women.
    icon representing item origin Origins
    Made in Berlin, Ohio, United States of America
    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Gossner Foods Mild Cheddar Slice

    $3.85 Shop now launch
    View description
    From humble beginnings in the village of Cheddar, England to the grand Poobah of go-to cheese for any occasion, Cheddar has been centuries in the making. And we've refined and perfected the craft of making the world's best here at Gossner's. Aged a minimum of 60 days, our mild, medium and sharp cheddar has an unparalle

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    rBST Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Hoosier Hill Farm White Cheddar Cheese Powder - Hoosier Hill Farm

    $17.98 Shop now launch
    View description
    Hoosier Hill Farms White Cheddar Cheese Powder is made with microbial rennet rather than rennet made from animal sources. Shop our online store today!

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Gluten Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Cato Corner Farm Black Ledge Blue Cato Corner Farm

    $15.00 Shop now launch
    View description
    A natural rind blue with a gorgeous yellow color speckled with blue.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Hormone Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Cato Corner Farm Bloomsday Cato Corner Farm

    $15.00 Shop now launch
    View description
    A hugely successful mistake! We created this recipe out of necessity when a different batch did not go as planned, and we love the result.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Hormone Free

    1
    in Cheddar Cheese

    Cato Corner Farm Aged Bloomsday Cato Corner Farm

    $19.00 Shop now launch
    View description
    As featured in Yankee Magazine! Our Aged Bloomsday is 11 - 12 months old for a sharper and more intense finish - think a cheddary bite that's balanced by a touch of sweetness.

    Scored Product Attributes

    1
    icon representing Social criteria factor icon representing Enviro criteria factor icon representing Quality criteria factor Materials

    Hormone Free

    Your Selections

    Select 2 to 5 items to compare